Skip to main content
Lesson 13 of 36
Don't Assume Rationality
Drop Date: November 2026
Don't Assume Rationality

Lesson 13: Don’t assume an aggressor is rational.

Not every perceived aggressor will be thinking clearly. An attacker might be drunk, high, injured, disoriented, mentally ill, or acting irrationally for reasons you don’t know. If you expect logical behavior, you may misread the danger and escalate a situation that could have been defused. A confused stranger in distress might appear subjectively threatening to you, but your response must still be objectively reasonable under the law.

Lesson 13: Podcast

Not every perceived aggressor will be thinking clearly. An attacker might be drunk, high, injured, disoriented,...

Lesson 13: Expert Review

Not every perceived aggressor will be thinking clearly. An attacker might be drunk, high, injured, disoriented,...

Who’s Really at the Door?

Ted Wafer shot and killed Renisha McBride through the locked screen door of his home in Dearborn Heights, Michigan,...

Don’t Expect Them to Back Down

By: Shawn Vincent Just after seven in the morning on December 30, 2019, 34-year-old Jeffrey Smith stopped for gas and...

Irrationality on the Roadside

By: Shawn Vincent On the evening of January 29, 2014, Gerald Strebendt shot and killed David Crofut on the Bob Straub...

About Shawn Vincent

Litigation Consultant

Shawn Vincent is a litigation consultant who helps select juries in self-defense cases, and he manages public interest of high-profile legal matters.